James Young's Challenge to critics.

 James Young's 2nd Challenge to  

unclefeedle.

Challenge to unclefeedle. 

Feedle, you may remember, is an avowed critic of Astrology who runs a forum he describes as 'A fair and uncensored debate' - a witch hunt in other words. His fair-mindedness extends to describing Astrology as. 'A steaming crock of s**t'. He is also a keen supporter of the Great Randi-Pandi, all of which tells you a great deal about his so-called impartiality. 

So here is the deal. Feedle asserts that Astrology is nonsense and doesn't work. According to Feedle, 'It is not HOW Astrology works - but IF it works'. I will gladly prove him wrong by reading his chart and publishing a report of my findings for all to see. I am quite content to let the public be the judge. All he needs to do is supply me with his birth data and I will oblige, or will he continue to be so bigoted that he will will run away, rather like he did with my other challenge?  Still awaiting his reply. 

Apply here. 

Update. Feedle has predictably failed to respond, preferring to escape to the sanctity of his cronies, therefore he has failed the challenge.  

James Young's 2nd Challenge to  

shanedk [Shane Killian]

He we have a major player in the critics league. Shanedk specialises in saving the world from the so-called evil of Astrology and is an avid supporter of the Great Randi-Pandi. This critic likes to make lengthy videos in which he rants and raves like a lunatic, occasionally shouting at the camera. He also takes large sections of my own videos without permission and then tries to hold them up to ridicule. His excuse for this despicable behaviour is that it is 'fair use' and 'educational'. Shanedk also gets his facts horribly wrong by making gross assumptions - 'Sun conjunct Gemini' for example. In fact his knowledge of Astrology is abysmal - probably the worst I have ever come across.

So here is the deal. I will gladly prove him wrong by reading his chart and publishing a report of my findings for all to see so that you the public may be the judge. All he needs to do is supply me with his birth data and I will oblige. 

He may apply here.   

Latest update:  'Screaming' shanedk has so far failed to take up the challenge. I wonder why?